Half a Soul by Olivia Atwater
Started: 10/25/21
Finished: 10/26/21
Recommended to me as fantasy and manners, in a series called Regency Faerie Tales, and how could I not love it?
fairy
The Absolute Book by Elizabeth Knox
Started: 6/11/21
Gave up: 6/21/21
REALLY really good, except for one interlude that slowed the whole book down, and then the last quarter, which had both too much information and not enough information. I would still recommend it. I liked it.
Tam Lin by Pamela Dean
Started: 8/9/20
Finished: 8/14/20
I don’t know how to talk about this one without spoilers. First, several authors and reviewers I trust LOVE this book. I know the story of Tam Lin because I’ve read two other adaptations of it (Rose and Rot by Kat Howard, which I really enjoyed, and Fire and Hemlock by Diana Wynne Jones, which, according to these same authors and reviewers, should also have been a life-changing experience – it was not). Since I knew the story already, I was looking for clues early and pretty sure I was seeing them, but OH MY GOD this story took forEVER to get to the point, and then it rushed through EVERYthing right at the end. And left a lot of questions. NOT lifechanging for me. Maybe if I’d read it at a younger age…or maybe not.
In An Absent Dream by Seanan McGuire
Started: 7/5/20
Finished: 7/8/20
Fourth in the Wayward Children series, this one takes one of our characters back in time to when she found her door. It’s so good, and the ending is so sad. It felt sadder than the others, but I’m not sure why – they’re all sad stories because they can’t find their way back to where they feel they belong. I should re-read the first one, at least.
The Lost Sisters by Holly Black
Started: 2/1/20
Finished: 2/2/20
A novella about the main characters of the Folk of the Air trilogy, set between the first and second books. Nice to have part of the story told from the point of view of the other sister.
The Queen of Nothing by Holly Black
Started: 1/24/20
Finished: 1/28/20
Last in the fairy trilogy by Holly Black. Satisfying.
The Wicked King by Holly Black
Started: 1/11/20
Finished: 1/16/20
Second in the fairy trilogy by Holly Black. Good middle book. Great ending.
The Cruel Prince by Holly Black
Started: 1/4/20
Finished: 1/10/20
I’ve read (and liked) one other fairy story by Holly Black, and she’s a guest of honor at a convention we’re going to, so I figured I’d read more of her stuff. This is the first in a trilogy, also about the Fae (you can’t just call them fairies when they’re trying to kill you). It starts off DARK (bad stuff happens to some kids under 10 before they get packed off to live in Faerie), and then we jump ahead ten years and follow them as teenagers.
Fire and Hemlock by Diana Wynne Jones
Started: 8/12/19
Finished: 8/18/19
Another book that was good but one I don’t know if I liked. It’s a coming of age story, but the framing device was a little confusing…and then I was totally engrossed in the story, and the framing device sort of starts to make sense near the end (most of the story is within the frame, so it doesn’t matter in the moment), but then the very end made NO sense to me. The book includes an essay by the author about the themes and inspirations, and I can tell you I missed all of that. It did make everything make more sense, and I don’t mean to say that the book didn’t make sense (except for the end, which was confusing), and now I’m not making sense, so I’ll end by saying that this book could be taught in a literature course and the students would get a lot out of it.
The Rose MacGregor Drinking and Admiration Society by Ursula Vernon
Started: 7/27/19
Finished: 7/27/19
SHORT short story, with a cute twist on the sly faerie folk genre.
The Iron Dragon’s Daughter by Michael Swanwick
Started: 2/5/19
Gave up: 2/7/19
This could have been (and might be, to a different reader) an interesting story about belonging and ownership of self and taking action to control your life, but it felt like several stories all muddled together. It starts in a factory with child labor, but it leaves there quickly (and abruptly), with no sign any of that will be revisited. Then it switches to a school, with great details about tiny things that appear to have nothing to do with the plot (but they’re neat). In both settings so far, there are off-hand crude comments involving sexualizing young girls that I found really disturbing. We’re following one main character, but I have no idea what she’s going to do or even what she wants to do. I gave it up.
Ash by Malinda Lo
Started: 1/28/19
Finished: 1/30/19
I like fairy tale retellings, and I very much enjoyed this Cinderella retelling with actual fairies (like the fae, the cannot-be-trusted types) in the background.
Wintersong by S. Jae-Jones
Started: 1/13/19
Finished: 1/14/19
The Goblin King in this book is SO very David Bowie, which is great. I think the characterization of the main character shifts halfway through, and not for the better. Her motivations aren’t consistent, and she gets all worked up about things that could be resolved if she would just TALK to the guy. Same goes for him, of course. On the other hand, she’s a teenager, and she’s acting like a teenager, so maybe I should be praising the author for her realism instead.
Under the Pendulum Sun by Jeannette Ng
Started: 8/16/18
Gave up: 8/17/18
Interesting premise: Victorian missionaries travel to the lands of the Fae to try to convert them to Christianity. Our protagonist’s brother never returned, so she heads there to try to find him. And then nothing happens. For a long time. So I gave up.
Rosemary and Rue by Seanan McGuire
Started: 6/17/18
Finished: 6/23/18
First book in the October Daye series. I love all things Seanan McGuire, so it’s no surprise I enjoyed this. There are at least 10 books in the series already, and I’m looking forward to reading them all. Fairies, detectives, alliances, set in the present day. My cup of tea.
Down Among the Sticks and Bones by Seanan McGuire
Started: 1/27/18
Finished: 1/28/18
Another novella, the second in the Wayward Children series. Very good, maybe not as good as the first one, but still really nice to dig into the actual through-the-looking-glass story of two of the characters.